- One recent analysis concluded that highly engineered consumables could be just as habit-forming as tobacco products.
- The study authors found that these foods are formulated to heighten pleasure and accelerate the absorption of reinforcing components.
- The “addictive” quality of these foods means they drive compulsive consumption and interfere with appetite regulation.
- Study contributors suggest that UPFs should be governed by regulations akin to those for tobacco products.
Right now, there is no one agreed-upon definition of UPFs. Some people describe them as foods that include components you would not typically use in a domestic pantry, such as emulsifiers and additives.
Numerous experts use the NOVA food categorization to classify UPFs. This describes products that contain “formulations of ingredients, mostly of exclusive industrial use, typically created by a series of factory processes and methods.”
A recent analysis released by The Millbank Quarterly proposed that UPFs may be as addictive as cigarettes.
“It is my view with these findings, as UPFs are specifically engineered to be incredibly tempting to the majority of people,” noted a bariatric surgeon not affiliated with the study.
Research from 2023 estimates that over 73% of the foods available in the US is classified as ultraprocessed.
“Tobacco and UPFs are not just natural products but scientifically formulated consumable products designed specifically to optimize physical and mental reward and compulsive consumption,” wrote the new study’s scientists.
Are UPFs Habit-Forming?
The paper combined findings from addiction, public health history, and nutrition to pinpoint sensory and structural qualities that enhance the reinforcing potential of both tobacco and ultraprocessed foods.
“It’s not all people is ‘addicted’’ to such products, but for a meaningful minority, they cause classic habit-forming behaviors: intense desires, loss of control, and continued use even with harmful consequences,” said a heart health nutrition expert.
“These foods are purposely formulated with processed carbohydrates, added fats, sodium, and taste additives to maximize reward and ongoing intake, and the food sector uses persuasive advertising strategies, particularly aimed at young people,” she continued.
Scientists analyzed five key areas:
- delivery speed
- hedonic engineering, or creating products to be extremely pleasurable
- dose optimization
- widespread availability
- misleading changes, or “wellness branding”
It was observed that, similar to cigarettes, ultraprocessed foods are carefully calibrated to deliver the right dose of sweetness.
“Refined carbohydrates stimulate the feel-good chemical production through the a key neural pathway, whereas fats do so via fat detection in the gut,” the authors explained.
“… Ultraprocessed foods with significant amounts of processed carbs and extra oils are among the most strongly reinforcing substances in the modern diet. Notably this processed carb and fat combination is virtually absent in whole foods.”
The way such products quickly deliver “feel-good” chemicals to the brain makes them likely habit-forming, similarly to tobacco.
The paper noted that while tobacco are designed to deliver nicotine quickly, UPFs are formulated to be broken down and absorbed quickly, as they typically have little to no dietary fiber. This allows for the system to metabolize lipids and carbohydrates faster.
The researchers also explain that UPFs give intentional flavor bursts that dissipate rapidly and mouthfeels that dissolve easily. This all helps to trigger increased pleasure signals and encourages individuals to eat more.
‘Health Washing’ in Cigarettes, UPFs
According to the analysis, both the cigarette and processed food sectors have historically employed a strategy known as “wellness branding.”
This is when products are marketed and reformulated to create an illusion of reduced harm while preserving the core addictive qualities.
Health washing in the cigarette sector became popular in the 1950s with the advent of filters on cigarettes.
They were marketed as safety features that would trap tar and particles before they reached the respiratory system. In reality, filters offer little meaningful protection.
Yet, people typically adapted by taking bigger puffs or smoking more frequently, which offset any decrease in toxin exposure.
The food industry has adopted a comparable strategy. It employs packaging claims like “reduced fat” or “sugar-free” to promote ultraprocessed foods.
Yet, these items still contain the very addictive formulations. The issue is that these changes present a superficial impression of health while the item’s habit-forming nature and metabolic harms persist unchanged.
Should UPFs Be Regulated?
The authors noted at the end of their review that nourishment and smoking products are fundamentally different.
Still, they warned that certain UPFs act like highly optimized products rather than actual food. They proposed that health regulations should reflect this distinction.
“Tobacco provides a warning, and smoking regulations provides a model of potential,” the researchers stated.
Due to policies, smoking levels in the United States have fallen and have “altered public perception of smoking and diminished confidence in the sector.”
“It is my opinion greater awareness about the harmful effects of UPFs is crucial to lower general consumption and improve public health. The approaches used to curb cigarette use have been effective and could be a helpful model for UPFs as well,” commented one expert.
“I don’t think UPFs ought to be controlled exactly as cigarettes, but they certainly deserve more robust, tobacco-inspired measures: marketing restrictions, obvious front-of-package labeling, stricter standards on wellness assertions, and limits in schools or medical facilities,” added another dietitian.
The researchers pointed out to people that lightly altered and unprocessed foods have sustained human health for millennia.